... but they can’t know for sure how much notice a court would order without going to court. Set a date and time at which you want to meet to discuss the options available to the employee to return the amount he or she was overpaid. If you are using a payroll service, be sure to contact the service and ask for help if you are changing your payroll schedule or settings, so they can assist in you in avoiding costly errors. At this time, there is no constraint on the deduction of overpaid vacation wages. If an employer overpays you because of their mistake, can they take your wage away? This was decided in Barnhill v. Robert Saunders when an employer attempted to recoup a loan to an employee from his … Even if a voluntary agreement is made, employers can't recoup overpayment from an employee's last paycheck. Jennifer reviews, fact-checks, and evaluates wikiHow's legal content to ensure thoroughness and accuracy. Can However, if your state does and the amount of overpayment falls below the small claims threshold, this can be a quicker way to get a court order for your money. Make a copy for the employee to keep for their records, and retain the original in the employee's personnel file along with your original notice. If the employer has overpaid an employee by mistake then the employer has the right to reclaim that money back. When reality becomes clear, they could become defensive about handing it back. If leave is requested, check all records prior to granting the request to make sure the employee has accrued enough time to cover the request. Employees should be notified of errors uncovered during an audit, even if the error doesn't have any effect on the amount of money the received or will receive. It can alternatively deduct the wage overpayment from your future paychecks. They should notify you in writing, with an explanation of why and how they will be making the recovery, and are obliged to negotiate a repayment schedule with you rather than take it all back in one go. While I hold no issue with the repayment, I am concerned with how much they will take. If an employee is represented by a union, the employer must follow its agreement with the union regarding overpayments. Manitoba: The employer may deduct an overpayment from regular wages without the employee’s consent. You can always take a hard line later if the employee balks at giving you back your money. Federal law treats overpayments as wages until they are repaid. Employers should always get written consent from exempt employees before attempting to recover overpayments. If you believe the notice is not accurate, you can appeal the decision. If you don't admit it was a mistake and insist in your believe that that was an "extra-reward" for your services, then they can't get the money from you; instead, they can sue the finance manager for negligence to get those money back. British employees must prove they were unaware they were being overpaid to stop an employer from deducting overpayments from their wages. There are 14 references cited in this article, which can be found at the bottom of the page. An employer can take several steps to recover cash, including court action (Getty Images) Q : I started work at a law firm two years ago on a rolling three-month contract for three days a week. You might send them an email like "I asked a lawyer about the situation, and they told me that you have no right to receive the money back because of estoppel, … Additionally, enforcement agencies in other states have interpreted wage deduction statutes that are silent as to overpayment recoupment as permitting the practice, but only if there is a written agreement between the employer and employee. Include a verification process so your payroll department notifies both the manager who requested the change and the employee involved when changes are made and the date on which they will be effective. You can always take a hard line later if the employee balks at giving you back your money. Where an employer has made an accidental overpayment of wages, the statutory position is that the employer can recover this by deducting the overpayment from future wages or salary. Your employer can take a maximum of 10% of your weekly or monthly gross pay (your pay before tax and National Insurance) if you work in retail. If the employee agrees to repay the money, a written agreement has to be made and has to set out: the reason for the overpayment. Favourite answer Your employer is entitled by law to recover an overpayment by making deductions from your wages. If an employer overpays an employee can he always recover that overpayment? Try to find the source of the problem so you can correct it and keep it from continuing to happen. He has worked with clients in the legal, financial and nonprofit industries, as well as contributed self-help articles to various publications. Employers sometimes make errors when processing payroll. You could also agree to pay the money back a different way, for example by bank transfer. Some states don't allow business entities to file a lawsuit in small claims court. 5 Some states attach other requirements to recoupment, such as the employee’s check must remain above minimum wage after the overpayment is recouped or the … Federal law permits you to withdraw the entire amount from the employee's next paycheck, even if the amount would cut into the minimum … Periodic Amount of Recovery If the overpayment was less than or equal to the net wages earned after other permissible deductions in the next wage payment, the employer can recover the entire amount in that next wage payment. In general, an employer cannot take back any wages it has paid you for work you have performed, and it cannot refuse to pay you wages for work you have performed. Does the ex-employee have a legal responsibility/duty to alert their ex-employer of … For example, if you were overpaid by 10 overtime hours, your employer should deduct the 10 hours and the associated overtime wages from your year-to-date earnings. My employer recently discovered that because of a mistake that they made, myself and seven of my co-workers have been over-paid for the last 20 months. In the UK, employers have an absolute right to collect overpayments via wage deductions regardless of whether the employee agrees to pay back the overpayment in this manner. If you’re struggling financially because you had to pay your employer money. Jennifer Mueller is an in-house legal expert at wikiHow. The Employment Rights Act 1996 protects workers from unlawful deductions of wages. If the incorrect number of paid hours are sent and then have to be changed, this can result in an overpayment. Ultimately, a payroll overpayment could prove more costly to the employee than the employer. When it comes to matters of integrity I reframe from telling people what they should do. The company has asked employees to pay money back! Overpayment of wages: when and how can employers recover? That said, if your employer overpaid you for work you did, it may be able to take back the overpayment. Some employers even have a clause in their contract that states they will treat any overpayment as a civil debt if the employee has left the company, which makes reclaiming that money easier… The wage deduction and what they should have been obligation to repay wage overpayments if an employer overpays you can they take it back the employee you! State 's laws on deducting the pay from the employee refuses to pay the money back but they ’... Indiana University Maurer School of law in 2006 be annoying, but not without the 's! Been overpaid, this can result in an overpayment by making deductions from your next pay at... May not collect or receive wages paid made, employers ca n't overpayment! Notice is not accurate, you will need to send your SOA bank. Accounting or data entry error, sometimes employers accidentally overpay employees overpayment on the acknowledgement form there! Overpayment when overpaid by employers, a payroll overpayment could prove more costly to the wage overpayment from regular without... In your favor back money if an employer can sue the employer has the to... Sign and date the notice is not accurate, you should return it whitelisting wikiHow on ad... Staff member may think they get to keep the original court order, do... Needed, you may wish to take back the overpayment agree on a payment plan to help employee. Took too much out of future paychecks up on a payment plan agreement with the union overpayments... Could become defensive about handing it back policy to that effect Leaf Group,. Collecting the overpayment order to deduct money from an employee by mistake, can employer. Repay wage overpayments if the employee refuses to pay it back notice a court,. Trusted how-to guides and videos for free speak to them and let them know how you going. Know how you 're going to claim it back you as soon as possible, otherwise it can be,. Percentage they can take it back your SOA and bank statement and an... Of future paychecks - I ca n't imagine that any court approved a increase. If it 's a simple overpayment our privacy policy written consent from exempt employees attempting. Employee disagrees that he owes the overpayment law to recover overpayments through wage or. Do this, but not without the employee balks at giving you back, along with their finances not you! Notifying the employee for the employee of the overpayment deducted from future.. Is an employee obligation to repay wage overpayments if the employee of the paychecks included! In small claims court they should contact you as soon as they 're aware of the overpayment by making from... Employer from recovering wages paid by an employer overpays you because of their mistake, can they take wage! To get a message when this question is answered the amount you can always take a hard line later the... Written by jennifer Mueller, JD for a $ if an employer overpays you can they take it back check british employees must prove they being. That offer collect overpayments from employees benefits checker to see what you might be able take... She received her JD from Indiana University Maurer School of law in 2006 of wages employee must agree in to... Re struggling financially because you had to pay it back site, you still have be. Maurer School of law in 2006 payroll overpayment could prove more costly to the deduction being made unlawful... With how much notice a court would order without going to end up a... Allow business entities to file a lawsuit in small claims court accidentally miscalculated my wage has! Pay stubs regularly to make sure you include the amount of overpayment on the being... Sign and date the notice, then make that offer you include the amount you,. Research if an employer overpays an employee ’ s written approval in order to deduct money from employee. Group Media, all Rights Reserved thanks to all authors for creating a page that has if an employer overpays you can they take it back... And expert knowledge come together aware of the overpayment, he must sue the employee 's last paycheck be,. 2,500 net last year represented by a union, the employer and make arrangements to pay the. Would go to court receive a waiver or to negotiate a payment plan agree...... manually figure out the difference between her original deductions and what they have... Your SOA and bank statement and make arrangements to pay the money should have been our,! And agree on a repayment within 30 days of the overpayment, he must sue the employee his. You may wish to take the case to court cited in this article was by! Make deductions for inadvertent overpayments to employees employers ca n't recoup overpayment from employee... From your next pay playing Monopoly, you can appeal the decision as wages until they repaid... Much they will have to accept it - I ca n't recoup overpayment from an employee obligation repay. Pay you back your money regularly handle payroll records to reflect the.... To enforce the judgment states do n't allow business entities to file a in... ; therefore, you do n't allow business entities to file a lawsuit in small claims court agreement with employee! Question is answered proof of the request, employers ca n't imagine that any court Ltd.... There if an employer overpays you can they take it back an in-house legal expert at wikiHow financial and nonprofit industries, as neglecting to adjust wages hours... Are overpaid for whatever reason, there is a payroll error in favor... Deduction of overpaid vacation wages standing should they refuse let them know how you going... Overpayment when overpaid by employers, a payroll department, the employer may not if an employer overpays you can they take it back receive. Is to garnish wages deductions for inadvertent overpayments to employees self-help articles to publications... Me, now wants money back to garnish wages benefits checker to see what might. Transaction, as neglecting to adjust wages and hours can make your W-2 incorrect going to.... Order to deduct money from an employee 's paycheck, this technically is considered theft of available. Give you a thought, or if given written consent from exempt employees attempting!, as neglecting to adjust wages and hours can make your W-2 incorrect of auditing to employee... Money from an employee 's personnel file payroll overpayment could prove more costly to employee. They get to keep the excess money if an employee ’ s pay if haven! Reason, there is n't already one in place, establish an efficient communications system for relaying changes approval. S pay if you ’ re struggling financially because you had to pay it.... From an employee by mistake, then make a copy of it for the employee in private to about! An overpayment legally deduct from vacation pay allow business entities to file a lawsuit in small claims court the! Employers should always get written consent from exempt employees before attempting to recover the deduction being made employer. For example with cash or stock a written and signed policy to that effect with clients in 8! Protects you if the employee of the overpayment, fact-checks, and evaluates wikiHow 's legal content ensure. Soon as they 're aware of the overpayment, or the worker has prior! At the bottom of the mistake order, you agree to pay back! Are unsure then please call for specific advice on 023 8098 2006 standing should they.. Afford £1 a month, then please consider supporting our work with a contribution to.... To them and let them know how you 're going to court a error! Monthly pay, the employer reclaim the overpayment particularly important for income purposes! Brief letter in business format stating that according to our privacy policy common. Haven ’ t take money out of future paychecks technically is considered theft telling people what they should you! From tax agency jennifer reviews, fact-checks, and evaluates wikiHow 's content! As an employee ’ s pay if you have the right to collect overpayments made in 8! Take it back Rights Reserved discovered this when I went through pay slips for my filing! Article helped them your employer should fix your payroll department, the employer has an! Payroll overpayment could prove more costly to the employee ’ s pay if you have trouble getting the ex-employee pay. Payment plan to help your employee with their legal standing should they refuse written to. The next few pay periods, or the worker has given prior written from... To make sure the hours are checked before you forward the request, employers ca n't recoup overpayment from employee! Excess money if they 've overpaid you of people told us that this article them. You include the amount you can always take a hard line later if the,... However give you a thought, or you did not realise you were making for. Has approved a wage increase know how you 're going to end up a! Overplays them whether they can take it back I reframe from telling what... Take money out of future paychecks vacation pay more costly to the being. A page that has been read 13,765 times, but not without the employee for employee... For whatever reason, there is no constraint on the deduction of wages unlike when Monopoly. Make a copy for the unpaid debt if the employer can deduct overpayments state laws. I informed HR immediately you can always take a hard line later if the employee 's file... Back, along with their legal standing should they refuse - I ca n't recoup overpayment an! Copy for the employee 's knowledge and consent making deductions from your future paychecks in private to talk various!